TruthfulPaws
Home / Adoption Data
The TruthfulPaws Adoption Data Project

Why animals wait. What 6 million shelter listings reveal.

An ongoing analysis of US shelter adoption data drawing on Petfinder listings from 2020 to today plus Shelter Animals Count outcome reports. The findings here challenge the standard story about adoption speed, breed bias, and which animals fall through the cracks. Updated monthly. No sponsored picks.

~6M listings analyzed · 2020–2026 coverage · Last updated April 2026 ·
The headline finding
596K

Nearly 600,000 dogs and cats were euthanized at US shelters in 2025.

320,000 dogs and 277,000 cats — about 1,630 animals every day. The rate varies dramatically by state. New Hampshire euthanizes 4% of dogs entering its shelters; Louisiana euthanizes 15%. Hawaii euthanizes 1 in 5 cats. Most US shelters report a live release rate of about 89% — but the 11% on the other side is the question this page exists to look at.

Source: Shelter Animals Count national database, 2025 aggregate · 6.9M animal outcomes across all 50 states. See methodology →
Why this page splits

Cats and dogs face structurally different pressures.

Cat listings swing across the year on kitten-season pressure — dogs swing 1.3×. Cat geography spreads 5.7× from fastest to slowest state — dogs spread 3.1×. The euthanasia gap by state is wider for cats too: Hawaii euthanizes 1 in 5 cats at the high end, vs roughly 1 in 7 for the worst dog states. The findings split by species below because the pressures aren't the same — averaging them would hide the differences that matter.

Six things we found · per species

The system that decides which animals get adopted has more to do with shelter operations than with the animals themselves.

Each of the findings below is sourced to specific cohorts and sample sizes. Click Copy on any of them to lift a citation-ready sentence with attribution. Detailed methodology at the bottom of the page.

01 / Geography
3.1×

Dogs listed in New Hampshire adopt three times faster than dogs listed in Texas.

Dogs published in New Hampshire averaged 39 days to adoption in 2024. Dogs published in Texas averaged 122. Texas listed 9× more dogs than NH (34,595 vs 3,772) — yet on a per-capita basis, NH lists more dogs per resident than TX, consistent with the rescue-transport pipeline that moves animals from high-supply Southern states to low-supply Northern destinations.

Cohort: 2024 adopted dogs · n ≈ 782K · method
02 / Puppies vs seniors
2.3×

Puppies adopt in 30 days. Senior dogs wait 70.

Puppies averaged 30 days to adoption in 2025. Senior dogs averaged 70. Adults and young adults sit between them at 60–63 days. The senior penalty is real but smaller than it is for cats — and adopters do still take older dogs.

Cohort: 2025 adopted dogs by age bucket · n = 436K · method
03 / Breed
2.6×

Goldendoodles adopt 2.6× faster than pit bull terriers.

Goldendoodles averaged 26 days to adoption in 2024 — the fastest breed in the dataset. Pit Bull Terriers averaged 68 days, the slowest. Designer mixes (Goldendoodle, Labradoodle, Maltese) cluster at the top of the speed list; pit-bull-family breeds (Pit Bull Terrier, American Staffordshire Terrier, American Bulldog) cluster at the bottom. America's most-listed dog — the Labrador Retriever, n = 26,441 — sits in the middle at 49 days.

Cohort: 2024 adopted dogs by primary breed (n ≥ 1,000 per breed) · within-year resolutions · method
04 / The "no" question
1.8days

Filing an honest "not good with kids" barely costs the dog at all — within the same shelter, the wait gap is 1.8 days.

Within the 282 shelters that file dogs as both "good with kids" and "not good with kids" (n=162K dogs in 2025), the average wait gap between the two labels is just 1.8 days. Adopters who want a kid-friendly dog match the dog to the family — they don't avoid the listings flagged "No." Filing an honest "not good with kids" essentially doesn't slow adoption.

Cohort: 2025 adopted dogs, within-org analysis · 282 orgs · n = 162K · method
05 / Seasonality
+30%

Summer brings 30% more dogs into the shelter system — and wait times rise to match.

June 2024 published 37,296 dog listings. December published 28,723 — a 30% summer surge that lines up with kitten/puppy season intake. Wait times follow: dogs listed in May wait 55 days on average; dogs listed in December wait 43. Same shelters, same animals, just more of them at once and fewer adopters out looking.

Cohort: 2024 dog listings by publish month · n = 384K · method
06 / Euthanasia by state
4.1×

Dog euthanasia rates vary 4× by state. New Hampshire euthanizes 3.6%; Louisiana euthanizes 14.9%.

Across 3.5M dog outcomes reported to Shelter Animals Count in 2025, the state-level dog euthanasia rate ranges from 3.6% in New Hampshire to 14.9% in Louisiana. New England states (NH, ME, VT, MA) cluster at the low end alongside the Pacific Northwest. Southern interior states (LA, AL, OK, KY) and parts of the Southwest sit at the high end. The same shelter-system geography that drives adoption-speed differences shows up in life-and-death outcomes.

Source: Shelter Animals Count, 2025 dog outcomes aggregate · n = 3.5M outcomes across 50 states. · method
Explore the data

See how shelter dynamics change by state, age, breed, and listing quality.

The interactive explorer lets you compare adoption speed across states, breeds, and demographics. Toggle between Petfinder listing data and Shelter Animals Count outcome reporting to see where the two tell different stories.

TruthfulPaws Adoption Explorer
Coming soon

Interactive explorer arriving in the next release.

State-by-state adoption speed, age × listing quality crosstabs, seasonality, and a Petfinder-vs-Shelter-Animals-Count reality check overlay. Want a preview when it ships? Get in touch.

Methodology

Where the data comes from. How we validate it.

Listings come from Petfinder's public search interface, scraped daily and deduplicated against a rolling snapshot. Outcome data — live release rate, euthanasia, transfers — comes from Shelter Animals Count's state-aggregate reports, which cover roughly 7,000 US shelters.

Coverage starts in 2020 and runs through the most recent monthly refresh. Per-finding methodology, validation steps, and known limitations are documented in the full methodology page. The raw research notebook is available on request to journalists, researchers, and shelter staff. We do not publish the raw Shelter Animals Count export — SAC's data-use agreement reserves redistribution rights.